Diddy 'Idol' Rumors Fly: Would He Make a Good Judge on the Show?

According to the New York Post, Sean “Diddy” Combs is being considered as a new judge on “American Idol” to fill one of the holes created by the departure of Steven Tyler and Jennifer Lopez. While other names like Nick Jonas and Pharrell Williams are also being tossed around, the Post wrote that Fox producers have reached out to the rap superstar to join the panel.

Diddy is certainly a monster in the music industry in his own right. The three-time Grammy-winning performer has released three multi-platinum albums including his debut “No Way Out” in 1997. He also founded Bad Boy Records, which since 1993 has featured artists like Notorious B.I.G., Faith Evans, Cassie and Janelle Monáe.

Plus, if all that isn’t enough, he has produced a long list of stars including Mary J.Blige, Jennifer Lopez, Limp Bizkit, Britney Spears and Jay-Z. Clearly his credentials in the music business stack up.

But Diddy also has another leg up over other potential judges: “Making The Band.” From 2002 to 2009 he went on the search to form the best hip-hop acts, boy bands and girl groups. The show churned out four somewhat-successful acts before ending its run. Clearly, this proves Diddy’s experience spotting vocal talent. Still some may think he leans too much towards hip hop and rap for the reality show's taste. What do you think: Would Diddy be a good “Idol” judge?