Dark Knight vs Twilight: Which fantasy movie ruled in 2008?

Question Entertainment

Dark Knight vs Twilight: Which fantasy movie ruled in 2008?

by Twilight HQ Posted December 08, 2008 21:14:14

3,621 answers
Read all 3,579 comments
+48 raves

Dark Knight ruled at the box office this summer and Twilight is the fall/winter fantasy pick, but which movie was more deserving of your hard earned cash this year?

Answers
Results

Top Comment

+13 / -2 Quantum December 15, 2008 22:49:18

Answered: Dark Knight
The Dark Knight is the second highest grossing movie of all time. Twilight hasn't even reached 150th highest grossing movie of all time. The Dark Knight has nothing fantasy about it. It is a crime epic with superheroes, not a fantasy movie.

Twilight is a chick book. No manly guy is ever, in a googolplex of years, going to see Twilight. I haven't. And, I never will. I don't like vampires and I don't like romance novels, ergo I don't like Twilight.

It depends on whether you are a guy or a girl. If you're a guy, go get The Dark Knight. If you're a girl, go get The Dark Knight and if you like romance and vampires, go see Twilight.
View thread

Sort By

Most Raves
Least Raves
Oldest
Newest

text size

Comments

+4
paramorefan95 December 15, 2008 23:15:14

Answered: Other (leave a comment)
u can't put twilight and the dark knight against each other! thts just not fair! they're both awesome movies!
+5 / -1
Jasmin December 15, 2008 23:08:09

Answered: Twilight
totaly twilight no dought about it
+6 / -1
Tinky December 15, 2008 23:07:54

Answered: Twilight
Of course Twilight was the fantasy movie that ruled 2008. There is no question about it and who ever chose Dark Knight knows NOTHING about fantasy if they didnt pick Twilight. TWILIGHT IS THE BEST MOVIE EVER!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! :)
+8
agentchewy December 15, 2008 23:07:30

Answered: Dark Knight
I prefer watching a psycho trying to destroy a super hero then love between to teenagers.
+2 / -1
rosalie... to agentchewy December 15, 2008 23:30:03

u people who like the dark night are CRAZY!!!Twilight is WAYYYYYYYYYYYYYY better!!
alice s... to rosalie... December 19, 2008 23:01:52

KAY SO HERES THE THING THEY ARE COMPLETELY DIFFERENT YET THERE STILL THE SAME.
TWILIGHT IS ABOUT VAMPIRES THE DARK NIGHT/BATMAN IS ABOUT A MAN NAMED BRUCE WAYNE WHO BECOMES THE BAT MAN AND FIGHTS AGAINST EVIL TO AVENGE HIS PARENTS. I HONESTLY CANT DECIED WHICH I LIKE BETTER BECAUSE THEY BOTH WHERE AMAZING!
EXEPT OF COUSE THE ACTOR WHO WAS BRUCE SUCKED AND SO DID KRISTEN S./ BELLA SWAN!

_STONE
Rina to agentchewy January 17, 2009 23:55:12

Love? What love? I just saw a two hormonal teens mistaking lust for genuine attraction.
+6
eldarion telcontar December 15, 2008 23:05:55

Answered: Dark Knight
Dark Knight was sooooooooooo much better than Twilight!!!!!!!!
+7
Jay December 15, 2008 23:05:44

Answered: Dark Knight
Dark Knight all the way!!! I mean I liked Twilight but it was not even in the same league as the Dark Knight. When I looked at this poll I was surprised when a majority of the people said Twilight. The special effects in DK were breathtaking while Twilight's were merely mediocre! Haha now I'm going to go watch it again for the umpteenth time ;)
alice s... to Jay December 19, 2008 23:03:09

YOU WATCHED TWILIGHT...ISN'T THAT KIND OF UNMANLY?
OR ARE YOU JUST A LADIES MAN THAT DOES WHAT EVER A GIRL WANTS YOU TO?
_STONE
Jay to alice s... December 20, 2008 00:20:57

ummm I'm a girl!!!
+6
GodofWar133 December 15, 2008 23:02:25 (edited)

Answered: Dark Knight
All the FUCKING way!!!!!!!!!!!! FUCK TWILIGHT!!!!!!!!!!!
+8
nomersy December 15, 2008 23:02:09

Answered: Dark Knight
no questions
the dark night is the best movie of all time, let alone this year
twilight is like the scum on the scum in the scum on the bottum of its shoe
+1
rosalie... to nomersy December 15, 2008 23:31:04

EXCUSE ME!TWILIGHT ISNT SCUM YOU ARE!
+1
nomersy to rosalie... December 16, 2008 00:04:08

well excuse me!
i was just comparing them!
atleast i dont go around calling people that!
alice s... to nomersy December 19, 2008 23:06:30

YAH WELL YOU STILL SUCK!
_STONE
alice s... to nomersy December 19, 2008 23:05:36

YOU SUCK!
YOUR A JERK YOU DESERVE TO GO TO HELL!
INFACT EDWARD CULLEN IS BETTER THAN YOU...YAH THATS RIGHT I WENT THERE!
YOU PROBBABLY DONT EVEN HAVE A GIRL FRIEND UNLIKE EDWARD!
YOUR PROBBABLY JUST A NERD SITTING AT HIS COMPUTER DROOLING OVER SOME CHICK WHO YOU DONT EVEN HAVE THE GUTS TO TALK TO.
UNLIKE EDWARD!

YOU SICK BASTURED!
YOU ........SCUMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM...

_STONE
nomersy to alice s... December 19, 2008 23:31:58

yeah i dont have a girlfrind because i am a GIRL and have a BOY FRIEND
and another thing edward cullen isnt even real there for cant be better than anyone
i dont really care what you think of me but just because i dont like what you like does not mean i deserve to go to hell why would you even say somthing like that to someone I dont think YOU should go to hell
and for anyone who did not get it the first time, i never said twilight was a horible movie it wasnt half bad actually, but in COMPARISON with the other movie given i said it was LIKE scum
im sorry that you did not get that
and im sorry that you feel that way about me
+3 / -1
ELLRUS December 15, 2008 22:58:59

Answered: Twilight
no questions! TWILIGHT....... NO BLOOD, NO GUNS.....
+1
PetiteNoir to ELLRUS December 18, 2008 00:16:52

Odviously you didn't watch Twilight all the way through. There was blood, no guns, but there was blood.
daggerg... to PetiteNoir March 15, 2009 02:36:15

there wasnt MUCH blood. the only blood that i saw, ahem..barely saw, was wen edward was saving bellas life after the fight seen. the only blood in the ENTIRE movie was during the 10 minute fight scene at the end of the movie.
PetiteNoir to daggerg... March 16, 2009 18:23:43

then you can't say there was NO blood.
+6
Gimms December 15, 2008 22:57:15

Answered: Dark Knight
Eeeeeeeh this is hard seeing as I love both.
But, The Dark Knight got my vote.
It's amazing.
+3 / -1
HangNoutWithCorpses December 15, 2008 22:55:15

Answered: Twilight
Kellan is the Sexiest Vampire Ever
and i apsolutly love the twilight books and the movie
alice s... to HangNou... December 19, 2008 23:07:35

ROCK ON GIRL!
+3 / -1
DaiRai December 15, 2008 22:54:12

Answered: Twilight
i mean dark night is great.....but i'll have to go with twilight it's amazing
+6
daniel December 15, 2008 22:54:04

Answered: Dark Knight
Dark Knight is a lot better than twilight.
+3
MrsEdwardCullen December 15, 2008 22:52:18

Answered: Twilight
definetly Twilight. no compition. period.
+13 / -2
Quantum December 15, 2008 22:49:18

Answered: Dark Knight
The Dark Knight is the second highest grossing movie of all time. Twilight hasn't even reached 150th highest grossing movie of all time. The Dark Knight has nothing fantasy about it. It is a crime epic with superheroes, not a fantasy movie.

Twilight is a chick book. No manly guy is ever, in a googolplex of years, going to see Twilight. I haven't. And, I never will. I don't like vampires and I don't like romance novels, ergo I don't like Twilight.

It depends on whether you are a guy or a girl. If you're a guy, go get The Dark Knight. If you're a girl, go get The Dark Knight and if you like romance and vampires, go see Twilight.
+2
potter101 to Quantum December 16, 2008 15:34:00

i think you are 100% right, most GIRLS like twilight because of the "hot" guy & the romantic scenes in the movie. i love romantic movies & i still think dark night is awsome & twilight sucks! ...........but thats just me. Or maybe its cuz im a H.P. fan! but i think dark night will take it all!!!!!!!!!;-}
-1
alice s... to potter101 December 19, 2008 23:10:34

HARRY POTTER SUCKS!
and this is coming from a former H.P. fan!
HE SUCKS BECAUSE HE'S BORING A NERD AND THERE IS NO RAMANCE!
I MEAN NO OFFENCE TO JK ROWLING BUT HONESTLY CAN WE GET TO THE PART WHRE VOLDY DIES?
YOU DRAG IT OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO... FOR EVER!
YOU POTTER101 ARE INSANE YOUR MENTAL!
SO JUST GO CRY IN THE CORNER WHEN HARRY "ALMOST" DIES.
potter101 to alice s... December 20, 2008 04:31:14

1st of all, if you are saying the ignorant things you just said, then you are not a H.P. fan YOU DUMB ASS!!!!!!!! & 2nd of all, Harry Potter has a little bitof everything! vampiers, worlocks, wizards, witches & even ROMANCE! YOU BLASTED ASS WHOLE!!!!!!!! so why don't you SHUT YOUR FUCKINGMOUTH YOU STUPID ASS TWIT!!!!
+1
KK to Quantum December 16, 2008 20:12:09

I love Twilight ,I love Vampires,im a big country girl {deep country} but i still love vampires {at times} , i hate batman..... I wish i was an vampire right now so i can kill you!!!!!! Everyone stop talking bad about Twilight and the new movies cooming soon Mrs.Stephinie Meyer did a great job making these books and letting them come into a movie!!! Thank you Mrs. Meyer!!!! I Love Edward {Rob Pattinson} and all the charcters!!!! i cant wait till New Moon, Eclips, and Breaking Dawn comes out on theaters and DVD's & i cant wait till Twilight come out on DVD!!!!
alice s... to KK December 19, 2008 23:13:07

OMG!
HOW CAN YOU LOVE A VAMPIRE AND NOT A BAT?
THERE PRACTICLY THE SAME THING.
ANY WAY I DIDN'T GO JUST TO SEE BATMAN I WENT TO GO SEE THE JOKER BECAUSE HEATH LEDGER WAS AAAAAAAAAAAAMAZING!
YES SIR!
SO JUST SHUT UP ABOUT HATING BAT MAN!
RIGHT NOW GIRLY!
moe to Quantum December 17, 2008 16:48:26

well you must be a big fat freak cause every girl wants to be edwards bella and every guy wants to be bella's edward this is tha best freakin movie EVER!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!...
alice s... to moe December 19, 2008 23:13:46

SO TRUE SO TRUE!
Rina to moe January 17, 2009 23:42:01

... I don't. Edward's a creepy, abusive stalker. Like hell I'd choose an emotionally abusive boyfriend over the sweetie I have. Spouting cheesy lines about how great your romantic partner is doesn't make you sweet, or a good boy/girlfriend. Your actions are what determine that, and Edward's actions show that he is controlling and emotionally abusive.

And Bella's a shallow bitch. I wouldn't want to go out with her either.
+1
Indigo ... to Quantum December 17, 2008 18:54:47

The Dark Knight is one of the best movies I've ever seen. I don't think Twilight can compare to it.

I like Vampires but as far as movies go, the Dark Knight topped it by 100%.
twiligh... to Indigo ... December 21, 2008 16:08:23

no, i dont think so.
uchihak... to Indigo ... December 30, 2008 07:18:06

I totally agree... I'm a girl, and I'm not exactly bowled over Twilight. It's a disappointing film-.-

TDK rocks^^