Quantcast

Billy Crystal Will Host the Oscars: Too Funny or Too Old?

SodaHead Celebs 2011/11/11 19:41:28
You!
Add Photos & Videos
A few days ago, we learned that Eddie Murphy had officially backed out of hosting the Oscars so we asked you guys who the replacement host should be. Well, sadly, the Academy didn't take our advice because Neil Patrick Harris isn't hosting the awards like the majority of you wanted. Instead, Billy Crystal is hosting the Oscars.

billy crystal billy crystal oscars host oscars

The "When Harry Met Sally" actor casually tweeted this message Thursday afternoon: "Am doing the Oscars so the young woman in the pharmacy will stop asking my name when I pick up my prescriptions. Looking forward to the show." The funny thing is, that probably is the reason Billy Crystal is doing the show.

To people of his generation, the guy is a classic actor who used to belong on the A list. But to the new generation, he's kind of just a creepy looking guy that was in that one romantic comedy your mom still talks about.

We get it. The Academy is probably just really confused. They went with two young actors hosting last year -- Anne Hathaway and James Franco -- and it didn't go over so well. So now they're going with an oldie-but-a-goodie, Billy Crystal.

Who knows how ratings will fare this time around, but we've got to ask: do you think Billy Crystal is a good pick for Oscars host -- or is he old news?
Add a comment above

Top Opinion

  • TCFla 2011/11/12 23:42:45
    Too Funny
    TCFla
    +14
    What does his age have to do with it? Bob Hope, Jack Benny, Jimmy Durante, etc., entertained well into their Golden Years and were always entertaining. This is a very stupid question, SH.

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • doc moto 2011/12/09 22:13:16
    Too Funny
    doc moto
    Best city-slicking cowboy to host the deal; still crazy and still Billy!
  • thksfrthmmrs 2011/11/14 23:32:40
    Too Old
    thksfrthmmrs
    Well, I'm too young to know who he is so......
    *derp*

    naruto derp
  • Lanikai 2011/11/14 21:50:42
    Too Funny
    Lanikai
    He is GREAT at the Oscars. Good for him and them. Should be hilarious this year.
  • EmEm 2011/11/14 19:42:55
    Too Funny
    EmEm
    Too funny or too old are a bit too limited in my opinion. Sure, Billy Crystal is a safe choice, and everybody knows he'll deliver, but the last couple of Academy Awards shows have been just so-so, they should've gone a little more risky. Eddie was the right kind of risk, and I'm sure there would've been many more like him who would've liked to have done it.
  • ThinkAboutIt! 2011/11/14 19:05:55
    Too Funny
    ThinkAboutIt!
    +1
    Mr Crystal is too classy for the Oscars.
  • kraftymomma1979 2011/11/14 15:07:21
    Too Funny
    kraftymomma1979
    +1
    I love me some Billy Crystal!
  • DS in Oak Ridge NC 2011/11/14 14:52:58
    Too Funny
    DS in Oak Ridge NC
    Billy C will get the job done. The event is really about the nominees and the ultimate Oscar winners, not a stage to boost / make the host's career. He/She may be the on-stage personality, but the real stars will be those making acceptance speeches IMHO. Go, Billy.
  • coach k 2011/11/14 13:40:08
    Too Funny
    coach k
    +2
    he was the best they ever had
  • Requiem 2011/11/14 01:54:40
    Too Old
    Requiem
    Again? I would have preferred Eddie Murphy to Billy Crystal.
  • Spinmetillifall 2011/11/13 21:45:41
    Too Funny
    Spinmetillifall
    +1
    That's hilarious!
  • Jacinta Scott 2011/11/13 21:29:23
    Too Old
    Jacinta Scott
    +1
    Not Too Funny - Not Too Old - TOO BORING!!!!
  • AMERICAN.FREEDOM 2011/11/13 21:24:01
    Too Funny
    AMERICAN.FREEDOM
    funny LOOKIN
  • Southern Man 2011/11/13 19:37:11
  • Lanikai Souther... 2011/11/14 21:52:14
    Lanikai
    +1
    I WISH they could get Carrie and Brad from the CMA's as well, that crap was SO funny. I normally yawn thru those shows (have a kid, have to watch) but the CMA's were hysterical. Music sucked, but.....
  • Souther... Lanikai 2011/11/14 22:03:23
  • Souther... Lanikai 2011/11/14 22:16:45
  • Lanikai Souther... 2011/11/14 22:18:50
    Lanikai
    +1
    LOL, it is pretty bad, but funny.
  • Cal 2011/11/13 18:57:04
    Too Old
    Cal
    I seriously have no idea who this is.
  • Lady Wi... Cal 2011/11/14 21:57:05
    Lady Winters
    Ever seen The Princess Bride? Monsters Inc? City Slickers?
  • Cal Lady Wi... 2011/11/14 22:36:27
    Cal
    Monsters Inc is the only one recognizable and that was a very long time ago
  • katie 2011/11/13 18:12:34
    Too Funny
    katie
    +1
    I love Billy Crystal. I bet none of u knew he was in the movie "Princess Bride".
  • asher katie 2011/11/13 22:07:53
    asher
    i actually did know that. i love it when he gets into that fight with his wife about love lol good stuff
  • Lady Wi... katie 2011/11/14 21:57:30
    Lady Winters
    who doesn't know that?
  • BELLA 2011/11/13 18:11:50
    Too Old
    BELLA
    Get sum1 who's is actually funny and who wont break a hip or have a heart attack on stage
  • Frank 2011/11/13 17:46:53
    Too Funny
    Frank
    +1
    he's ok, and will do a good job.
    Perosnally, I probably won't watch the exclusive club that if you're in you get an oscar, and if you are out you don't.....
  • 13Cloud88 2011/11/13 17:03:33
    Too Old
    13Cloud88
    Too irrelevant
  • EastIndianFemme 2011/11/13 16:22:49
    Too Funny
    EastIndianFemme
    +1
    He always made me laugh no matter what; so what's the problem? I own and love this movie:

    when harry met sally
  • Mrs. Wedgwood 2011/11/13 13:26:39 (edited)
    Too Funny
    Mrs. Wedgwood
    +1
    He's not "too" anything. He's a talented comedian.

    "Soap" was the funniest show on television. If you haven't seen it, you've missed one of the shows that changed television forever. The networks realized some people do have a more sophisticated sense of humor and not everybody likes "The Three Stooges."

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?...
  • boatchic 2011/11/13 12:52:42
    Too Old
    boatchic
    I changed vote from Too Funny. All Oscar hosts make jokes about the new hot actress or actor and when they're coming from an old guy it can get CREEPY.
  • Sir Bud 2011/11/13 11:45:28
    Too Funny
    Sir Bud
    Firstly,No one cant be too funny,but not funny enough.Secondly Billy has hosted the Oscars before and he did a great Job.One of the best ever.Great choice.
  • Playerazzi 2011/11/13 11:13:34
    Too Funny
    Playerazzi
    +1
    HEY, I GOT MY WISH !!!

    I voted for Billy Crystal when this question was asked just the other day.

    Too kewl!!
  • Katherine 2011/11/13 08:55:17
    Too Funny
    Katherine
    +1
    He and Bob Hope were the two best presenters, IMO. I think I've missed a couple, but Crystal has always been hysterical so I'm very happy he's doing it this year.

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?...
  • Wolfman 2011/11/13 08:51:13
    Too Funny
    Wolfman
    +2
    I don't care. I don't watch it.
  • Lady Wi... Wolfman 2011/11/14 21:58:31
    Lady Winters
    +1
    yeah, I kind of agree. I usually go back and watch the good clips later on the internet.
  • jim 2011/11/13 08:45:32
    Too Funny
    jim
    +4
    This insulting piece of crap question got 5 raves?
  • Resp 2011/11/13 05:48:25
    Too Old
    Resp
    He has become too chubby and too bald. Is that his forehead?
  • Illjwamh 2011/11/13 05:18:12 (edited)
    Too Funny
    Illjwamh
    +3
    In all the years I've watched the Oscars, he's the best host they've had. Well, he and Steve Martin. He's supposedly second only to Bob Hope (and literally is in number of times hosted) but I never got to see him so I can't say.
  • BonnieDeutsch 2011/11/13 05:08:24
    Too Funny
    BonnieDeutsch
    +2
    I'm insulted ! In my years he's probably only 25years old !!
  • MOMMA THOMAS 2011/11/13 04:40:56
    Too Funny
    MOMMA THOMAS
    +3
    TOO FUNNY IF THEY'D MAKE IT THE OLD THREESOME, ... ADD ROBIN AND WHOOPIE.
  • Nan 2011/11/13 04:35:28
    Too Funny
    Nan
    +1
    He'll be a great host and will keep things moving along too.

See Votes by State

The map above displays the winning answer by region.

Entertainment

2013/05/22 18:14:58

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals