Quantcast

Are the New York Knicks Officially Overrated?

SodaHead Sports 2012/03/12 19:00:00
You!
Add Photos & Videos
Just one month ago, everyone -- SodaHead.com and its readers included -- was raving about the New York Knicks point guard Jeremy Lin and the phenomenon that was known as Linsanity. Keyword: Was. All that momentum, all that hype, all the positivity around the Knicks is officially gone. But who is to blame for the Knicks' recent bad luck?

On Sunday, Lou Williams led the Philadelphia 76ers to victory over the Knicks at 106-94. It was the Knicks' fifth straight loss, despite having a healthy Carmelo Anthony back in the lineup. Once above .500 and primed to get rise up the Eastern Conference ranks, the Knicks are now 18-23 and a mediocre 11-10 at home in Madison Square Garden. Fans surely couldn't be happy with their team losing to city/team rival Philly at home.

Knicks center Amar'e Stoudemire scored only nine points and grabbed five rebounds. Anthony went 5-13 in field goals, while Lin went 5-18 with 14 points and seven assists -- and six turnovers. While Lin has gotten most of the attention, he has gone from a no name on the bench to a very solid starter making six figures in a month.

Compare that to All-Stars Anthony and Stoudemire who get paid far more and have higher expectations and haven't met them. Of course, if the Knicks don't make the playoffs, fair or unfair, the full blame could be put on head coach Mike D'Antoni. But whoever you want to blame might not matter right now. The Knicks have to fix whatever problems they have before they end up watching the playoffs from home. It's safe to say though that the New York Knicks, Jeremy Lin included, may officially be overrated.

knicks
Add a comment above

Top Opinion

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • topgundy7 2012/03/15 04:51:11
    Yes
    topgundy7
    Melo sucks as a team player!
  • Thatdude 2012/03/14 22:46:09
    Yes
    Thatdude
    Team is trash
  • Dylan Doherty 2012/03/14 16:22:14
    No
    Dylan Doherty
    +1
    they have there struggles like every other team
  • monkeylvr09 2012/03/14 15:01:11
    Yes
    monkeylvr09
    +1
    Jeremy Lin is an okay player. I personally like him, but when he was "Linsanity" and everyone raved about him, they were playing terrible teams. It just happens.
  • monkeyl... monkeyl... 2012/03/14 15:02:09
    monkeylvr09
    Go bulls(;
  • greg 2012/03/14 07:23:36
    Yes
    greg
    +1
    Carmelo Anthony is the biggest bust in the NBA
  • Maci 2012/03/13 17:40:56
  • @TheMissesHelp <-Follow/Twe... 2012/03/13 17:40:40
    Yes
    @TheMissesHelp <-Follow/Tweet me
    +1
    Always have been. Always will be. Celtics for life.

    TwitteR: #TheMissesHelp
  • david.perez1 2012/03/13 14:56:21
    No
    david.perez1
    +1
    This all started when the knicks traded for melo. Before him, stat was a monster. Since then start and melo just don't mesh. Now there is lin. While melo was injured, itwas called lInsanity. Since melo's return...blah. Get rid if him!
  • This is W³ 2012/03/13 13:56:38
    Yes
    This is W³
    +1
    Apparently so.

    The Knicks just need to get rid of Melo. The team was winning games without him and now they are losing games with him.
  • Jackal 2012/03/13 10:35:24
    No
    Jackal
    +2
    People need to understand that it is not the star player that wins games. It is the team the wins games. The greatest player can not carry a team. Knicks have two great players, but the rest of the team does not know how to work together. Jordan did not when because he was a great player though it helped. He won because his team was phenomenal. LeBron James should be a perfect example to all.


    Teams win games... not individuals.
  • Bob DiN 2012/03/13 07:22:53
    Yes
    Bob DiN
    Yup it started with Lin.
  • banzaibuckaroo 2012/03/13 06:30:05
    No
    banzaibuckaroo
    +3
    Their 18-24 for the season, and the Knicks starting forwards can't rebound to save their souls. That's the problem for this team.
  • landsiscool 2012/03/13 06:23:44
  • ronnie..its_his_war 2012/03/13 06:17:59
    Yes
    ronnie..its_his_war
    +1
    they just are because everyone talks about them when they aren't even that good.
  • Joey 2012/03/13 05:47:03
    Yes
    Joey
    +1
    People where going crazy over this dude as ... they beat a few times under .500, and the Lakers. People treated Lin like he was the best thing in Basketball when other players where putting up better numbers around the NBA at the same time .
  • NatAlex23 2012/03/13 05:18:10
    Yes
    NatAlex23
    +1
    The NBA is overrated. Basketball is the ONLY sport where I find the collegiate level more entertaining than the pro level.
  • Harry 2012/03/13 05:05:59
    Yes
    Harry
    +1
    Isn't it amazing how fast the Jeremy Lin madness faded?
  • Osk The Great Guru 2012/03/13 03:04:01
    Yes
    Osk The Great Guru
    +2
    Basketball is overrated too
  • wes 2012/03/13 02:29:20
    Yes
    wes
    +1
    Cutting your face while shaving has never been any fun in my book??
  • A Pigeon. 2012/03/13 02:02:47
    Yes
    A Pigeon.
    +2
    Basketball is over rated as it is. It's all about Football

    Baltimore Ravens
  • boiyaza 2012/03/13 01:32:02
    No
    boiyaza
    +2
    no jeremy lin is seems like his downfall came quicker then i thought it would
  • Cal 2012/03/13 01:31:51
    Yes
    Cal
    +4
    Basketball, in general, is overrated.
  • csonu 2012/03/13 01:02:48
    No
    csonu
    +1
    yo, ofcourse!
  • CraigPLewis 2012/03/13 00:59:50
    No
    CraigPLewis
    +1
    They're good Basketball players.
  • Ramnik Rasd 2012/03/13 00:59:29
    Yes
    Ramnik Rasd
  • keliffa 2012/03/13 00:29:19
    Yes
    keliffa
    LOL...every year.
  • Jim 2012/03/13 00:12:29
    Yes
    Jim
    The Knicks got a little carried away with a short winning streak.
  • H.E 2012/03/12 23:30:35
    No
    H.E
    +1
    Jeremy Lin has to get his confidence back. He's the key.
  • kelly 2012/03/12 22:46:00
    Yes
    kelly
    +1
    Aren't all sports teams overrated?
  • Riverz 2012/03/12 21:55:25
    Yes
    Riverz
    The most talked about team below .500 ever!
  • Splinter76 2012/03/12 20:21:53
    Yes
    Splinter76
    You mean they weren't before? Thanks, media.
  • Sterling 2012/03/12 19:31:33
    Yes
    Sterling
    +2
    As long as Mello is playing, they'll be overrated.
  • nighttrain8 2012/03/12 16:56:06
    Yes
    nighttrain8
    Odd question as I didn't even know they were rated. Loved the end of the philly game the other night with the knicks pressing and Philly starting their offense at 11 to 14. OH YA AND Mello was sitting...

See Votes by State

The map above displays the winning answer by region.

Entertainment

2013/05/24 22:11:49

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals