Quantcast

'American Idol' Crowns a Winner: Best Season Finale?

SodaHead Slideshows 2012/05/24 17:00:00

SLIDESHOW: Best Season Finale?

2 of 7

"Grey's Anatomy"

The season finale of "Grey's" might have been the most disturbing thing we've ever seen on TV. Ever.
  1. "American Idol"

    "American Idol"

    J-Lo in a sexy bra top! An Aerosmith concert! Rihanna! A live marriage proposal! These were only some of the highlights of Wednesday's finale, which crowned handsome 21-year-old Phillip Phillips the winner.

  2. "Grey's Anatomy"

    "Grey's Anatomy"

    The season finale of "Grey's" might have been the most disturbing thing we've ever seen on TV. Ever.

  3. "Desperate Housewives"

    "Desperate Housewives"

    The season finale was also the series finale. After eight years, we tuned in as the main characters moved away from Wisteria Lane, literally and figuratively.

  4. "House"

    "House"

    The series finale of "House" turned out to be quite a tearjerker. But it wasn't as sad as it initially appeared ...

  5. "Glee"

    "Glee"

    Some "Gleeks" graduated on this week's season finale … and some didn't.

  6. "NCIS"

    "NCIS"

    "NCIS" ended its ninth season with a bang … and a cliffhanger.

  7. "Saturday Night Live"

    "Saturday Night Live"

    Mick Jagger joined the cast to say goodbye to Kristen Wiig at her emotional "graduation" from the show.

'American Idol' Crowns a Winner: Best Season Finale?
You!
Add Photos & Videos
Jennifer Lopez in a sexy bra top! An Aerosmith concert! Rihanna! A live marriage proposal, and, lest we forget, a brand-new American Idol.



These were only some of the highlights of Wednesday night's "American Idol" finale, which crowned handsome (and talented) 21-year-old Phillip Phillips the season 11 winner. Yes, it's the fifth year in a row that a white guy won, but who's counting?

As usual, the "Idol" finale had something for everyone. Season three winner Fantasia joined third-place finalist Joshua Ledet (“Mantasia”) for a rollicking performance of Elton John’s classic, “Take Me to the Pilot.” Season five finalist Ace Young proposed to season three runner-up Diana DeGarmo, live on the "Idol" stage. And then there were the aforementioned performances from Rihanna, J-Lo and Aerosmith.

From "Idol" to "Grey's Anatomy" to "House," click through our slideshow and let us know: What was 2012's best season finale?
Add a comment above

Top Opinion

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • Luxxie 2012/05/25 03:34:53
    "Saturday Night Live"
    Luxxie
    +2
    i actually don't watch any of these shows on a regular basis. Best season finale for me was How i met your mother.
  • sally 2012/05/25 02:54:20
    "House"
    sally
    +2
    I was crying at the end...Then House....being the unpredicable ass he usually is TOTALLY surprised me with the fake death scene! I literally threw my control at the wall and was in total shock because I thought the bastard died! It was like for the first time he pulled one of his antics on the audience, it was weird but I loved it either way it was like now we got a feel for what everyone around him felt whenever he would pull something like this. I'm really gonna miss that show.

    As for Glee I haven't watched it yet but it's on my to-do list this weekend.

    DH sucked because I WANT TO KNOW WHAT THE HELL IS IN THAT BOX!

    Greys.....I hate whoever thought killing off Lexie was a good idea.

    So.....In all honesty I liked Phillip....Sure he had the good looks and charm but I just loved watching him and his voice sounds like the usual stuff I listen to. Jessica was definately the best singer but she's not as entertaining as he was. Honestly I would've perfered for Skylar or Colton to win... It's okay though, Jessica is pretty mainstream she'll have the backs of other people who like regular old pop ballads. I learned to appreciate the music Phillip plays and I started leaning towards him after he sang Disease and I really like what he did with Stand By Me. I thought last year sucked...
    I was crying at the end...Then House....being the unpredicable ass he usually is TOTALLY surprised me with the fake death scene! I literally threw my control at the wall and was in total shock because I thought the bastard died! It was like for the first time he pulled one of his antics on the audience, it was weird but I loved it either way it was like now we got a feel for what everyone around him felt whenever he would pull something like this. I'm really gonna miss that show.

    As for Glee I haven't watched it yet but it's on my to-do list this weekend.

    DH sucked because I WANT TO KNOW WHAT THE HELL IS IN THAT BOX!

    Greys.....I hate whoever thought killing off Lexie was a good idea.

    So.....In all honesty I liked Phillip....Sure he had the good looks and charm but I just loved watching him and his voice sounds like the usual stuff I listen to. Jessica was definately the best singer but she's not as entertaining as he was. Honestly I would've perfered for Skylar or Colton to win... It's okay though, Jessica is pretty mainstream she'll have the backs of other people who like regular old pop ballads. I learned to appreciate the music Phillip plays and I started leaning towards him after he sang Disease and I really like what he did with Stand By Me. I thought last year sucked. Once James was gone I didn't care for any of the people left. I didn't like either Lauren or Scotty that much. But even Phillip was in my top three. I bought some songs off of James' album and I'm pretty sure I'll buy something from my top three picks at least. Hollie wasn't that great in my opinion she was kind of boring to watch, just like Hayley last year but at least Hayley had a cool jazzy voice that made up for her lack of expression. Hollie was just boring in general.
    (more)
  • freakou... sally 2012/05/25 17:09:21
    freakoutnow... cuz mom's here
    I didn't like Scotty or Lauren that much either. It was too much Country music for a season finale. James Durbin was great as was Haley. I wanted Colton vs. Jessica and then Colton to win.
  • sally freakou... 2012/05/29 00:27:43
    sally
    +1
    Same here, Colton didn't deserve the early departure.
  • Meh 2012/05/25 02:51:06
    "American Idol"
    Meh
    +4
    Yay! I voted for him!
  • Aspect of B 2012/05/25 02:38:14
    "Grey's Anatomy"
    Aspect of B
    +2
    I picked Grey's even though I really didn't like it, but it's the only one I watched. I thought the Revenge finale was fantastic. Anybody else watch that show, or is it just me?

    revenge poster
  • ren Aspect ... 2012/05/25 18:46:35
    ren
    +1
    i agree with revenge. it was the best this year
  • DiViews2013 2012/05/25 01:48:57
    "American Idol"
    DiViews2013
    +3
    Phillip Phillips won based upon sympathy for his illness. The media leaked that he was holding off having a kidney transplant pending the AI finale. What an idiot!!!! Jessica, Joshua and Holly were all much better singers and will excel in the industry and Phillip will soon be forgotten. It will be just like Jennifer Hudson being voted off AI but, Fantasia won. Seems Jennifer has had the last laugh.
  • elptrek... DiViews... 2012/05/25 08:53:32
    elptrek P.H.A.E.T.'s wizard
    +2
    There are not too many Idol contestants that can hold their own with a grammy winner
  • lstl5 elptrek... 2012/05/25 15:22:06
    lstl5
    +1
    Dont like all that screaming.
  • DiViews... lstl5 2012/05/25 18:56:16
    DiViews2013
    +1
    Now this is screaming and I did not get a thing out of it. I hated this number. Joshua needs to rethink his mentor. However, what Jennifer and Jessica did was vocal prowess and testimonial singing. You must to take into account this song's intense meaning and context as a soul stirring power piece from a Broadway musical as it's sole origin. It is not really your typical love ballad and must be sung with powerful over the top emotion. ;)



    This is another of my favorite renditions of "And, I Am Telling You" by a 12 yr old.
  • lstl5 DiViews... 2012/05/25 19:49:57
    lstl5
    +1
    Ya, she gave me chills. Wow.
  • DiViews... elptrek... 2012/05/25 18:31:57
    DiViews2013
    +1
    You are spot on. I still have chills from their performance. I cannot believe Jennifer Holiday's vocal prowess has gust gotten even better. She really brought out a more skilled Jessica. To think Jessica is only 16 yr, she will be a force to be reckoned with in a couple of years.
  • elptrek... DiViews... 2012/05/26 05:50:48
    elptrek P.H.A.E.T.'s wizard
    +1
    I agree, where as Philip will only be heard of again when he does a guest appearance on Idol.
  • lstl5 DiViews... 2012/05/25 15:21:45
    lstl5
    +1
    So many winners have disappeared which is really strange.
  • DiViews... lstl5 2012/05/25 18:41:04
    DiViews2013
    +1
    All too often, the better performer are sent home or voted off too early. However, the real winners are chosen a couple of years after AI and I believe that will be the case for this for this season. Carrie Underwood won and she deserved it. Carrie and Jennifer Hudson have been two of the most talented ever of AIs. For me the rest have been mediocre performers until Jessica Sanchez.
  • elptrek... DiViews... 2012/05/25 19:27:49
    elptrek P.H.A.E.T.'s wizard
    +1
    You are forgetting about the original Idol Kelly Clarkson, the only other one that can truly be call a superstar.
  • AngelArs 2012/05/25 01:26:27
    "House"
    AngelArs
    +3
    I still can't believe that House will be off the air..... What an incredible show!
  • starlight 2012/05/25 01:01:30
    "Glee"
    starlight
    +1
    i love glee
  • Merry☆ 2012/05/25 00:45:55
    "Glee"
    Merry☆
    +1
    It was the only one I watched. I missed the entire last season of House, so I wasn't about to watch the finale... :/
    But actually, I thought the Glee finale was an enormous disappointment. I really enjoyed Kurt's graduation present from his father because I loved how it tied back to the very beginning of the series. It was both hilarious and touching... I wish I'd just stopped the episode right there.
    The very worst part of the episode was when Kurt found out that he didn't get into NYADA. Honestly, what lesson were we all supposed to learn from that? No matter how hard you try, you won't achieve your dreams? The girl who bombed her audition gets in, but you don't, even though you nailed yours? You never REALLY wanted to sing on Broadway, so go do something else? If they're trying to keep Chris on for another season, they've gone about it in the completely wrong way. You hurt Kurt, you hurt all of us, Glee.
    Also, Blaine and Kurt didn't kiss. Every other couple on the show kissed multiple times, but Blaine and Kurt didn't. I've had a huge problem with this for a long time, but it really hit hard on Tuesday's episode. I know that Fox has demonstrated that they hate homosexuals, but does it have to be SO obvious? I am so sick of holding my breath for the slightest of affection...
    It was the only one I watched. I missed the entire last season of House, so I wasn't about to watch the finale... :/
    But actually, I thought the Glee finale was an enormous disappointment. I really enjoyed Kurt's graduation present from his father because I loved how it tied back to the very beginning of the series. It was both hilarious and touching... I wish I'd just stopped the episode right there.
    The very worst part of the episode was when Kurt found out that he didn't get into NYADA. Honestly, what lesson were we all supposed to learn from that? No matter how hard you try, you won't achieve your dreams? The girl who bombed her audition gets in, but you don't, even though you nailed yours? You never REALLY wanted to sing on Broadway, so go do something else? If they're trying to keep Chris on for another season, they've gone about it in the completely wrong way. You hurt Kurt, you hurt all of us, Glee.
    Also, Blaine and Kurt didn't kiss. Every other couple on the show kissed multiple times, but Blaine and Kurt didn't. I've had a huge problem with this for a long time, but it really hit hard on Tuesday's episode. I know that Fox has demonstrated that they hate homosexuals, but does it have to be SO obvious? I am so sick of holding my breath for the slightest of affections between those two! It's like I'm an addict waiting for a hit of my drug.
    That all said, I love Glee. But god, I hate Glee. I'll be watching next season, anyway. Can't get enough of my bb Kurt. :')
    (more)
  • sally Merry☆ 2012/05/25 03:51:50
    sally
    +1
    What the hell???? THAT'S NOT FAIR! How could Kurt not get in? He nailed it perfectly and she got in? I protest Glee now...
  • Osk The Great Guru 2012/05/25 00:44:41
    "NCIS"
    Osk The Great Guru
    +3
    AI is overrated
  • Jacob 2012/05/25 00:35:31
    "House"
    Jacob
    +1
    Only one I watch but missed the ending :(
  • seahawk665 2012/05/25 00:18:18
    "House"
    seahawk665
    +1
    House was the only one I watched. I enjoyed it immensely, because it really drove home that House was like Sherlock. But it left me wondering what House was going to do after Wilson goes........
  • zacoholic 2012/05/24 23:49:03
    "American Idol"
    zacoholic
    +9
    I was so beyond happy when they announced Phillip Phillips as the winner! As soon as his name was said, my house was filled with the sound of me and my sister wooing as loud as we could! Finally, America's got it right!!! Go Phillip!!! :)
    Phillip phillips
  • Rob Williams 2012/05/24 23:44:26
    "House"
    Rob Williams
    +3
    I don't watch the UK's Pop Idol so I definitely don't watch American Idol.

    I've never seen NCIS or Grey's Anatomy so can't judge.

    I thought Desperate Housewives lost it after season 2.

    Glee was too painful to sit through! I think I managed about the first three episodes before I got cramp from the way the songs were being shoehorned into the plot!

    SNL is a classic but Kirsten is just the latest in a long line of exceptionally talented people moving on to greater things; pity her send off was spoilt by that doddery English pensioner who wandered onto the set!

    House was the one for me! I loved the way they kept twisting and turning until the end and I got a definite lump in my throat when the both rode off together.

    Also one of the things I always think when I see Hugh Laurie is "why can't I be him"! I mean... I had friends who went to Oxbridge so I could have done it if I'd worked harder, I'm the same age as Stephen Fry so I could have met him... it wouldn't take a lot to just cut him out of history and slot me in his place!
  • SK-LIBERTY OVER EQUALITY 2012/05/24 23:38:41
    "NCIS"
    SK-LIBERTY OVER EQUALITY
    +6
    I'd say AI has officially declared war on women. the shows rigged and will never watch this crap again.
  • Inquisi... SK-LIBE... 2012/05/24 23:43:29
    Inquisitve Kat
    +3
    I stopped watching it a few years ago... the best contestants never win.
  • Inquisitve Kat 2012/05/24 23:38:21
    "Glee"
    Inquisitve Kat
    +2
    Actually, the season finale was terrible, but it's the only season finale I saw of any of the shows listed.
  • Merry☆ Inquisi... 2012/05/25 00:48:37
    Merry☆
    +2
    It broke my heart. It broke. My. Fukken. Heart. Damn you, Glee! Why are they always stomping all over Kurt? :'(
  • Inquisi... Merry☆ 2012/05/25 06:18:48
    Inquisitve Kat
    I know... I would have been happier if he got in, instead of Rachel. She is the least likeable character.
  • Donna Wolf 2012/05/24 23:27:39
    "House"
    Donna Wolf
    +5
    I'm gonna miss that ole' Curmudgeon! greg house
  • Rob Wil... Donna Wolf 2012/05/24 23:48:45
    Rob Williams
    +2
    You and me both!

    It's funny, though, to watch alternating episodes of House and Blackadder the Third/Blackadder Goes Forth.... funny = strange that is!
  • tobe 2012/05/24 23:02:11
    "Grey's Anatomy"
    tobe
    +2
    american idol? you've gotta be kidding me.. the best singer on that shows long gone.. i thought these 2 woulda been voted off weeks ago.
  • heather... tobe 2012/05/25 15:33:01
    heathertraylor
    Was colton one of them? American idol gets worse every year. 16 year olds can't sing : /
  • tobe heather... 2012/05/25 16:44:34
    tobe
    nope. skylar laine...
  • DeeB 2012/05/24 23:00:09
    "American Idol"
    DeeB
    +8
    Phil Philips made me cry. He was my pick from the beginning. The kid is just fabulous. He was in total shock and it was very obvious. Congratulations Phil!
  • rightside DeeB 2012/05/25 05:49:50
    rightside
    +2
    Me too.
  • MJ rightside 2012/05/26 02:31:34
    MJ
    Actually her family didnt want her to win American Idol bc the first year of the new Idols carreer wutever they make 15% goes to American Idol and Jessica is already signed with Sony
  • Racefish 2012/05/24 22:25:42
    "American Idol"
    Racefish
    +6
    There's a finality. Next year new contestants.
    As for this year, I think Jessica blew everyone away. Maybe the country is tone deaf.

See Votes by State

The map above displays the winning answer by region.

Entertainment

2013/05/21 13:56:56

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals