Quantcast

Aerosmith vs Eagles?

☆The Rock☆ * AFCL* The Sheriff!! 2011/04/08 12:28:38
Aerosmith!
The Eagles!
Undecided
You!
Add Photos & Videos

This one is close but I have to go with Aerosmith!

Add a comment above

Top Opinion

Sort By
  • Most Raves
  • Least Raves
  • Oldest
  • Newest
Opinions

  • Moises Chavez 2011/06/29 08:56:00
    The Eagles!
    Moises Chavez
    +1
    The Eagles all the way, the highest selling American band in U.S. history, the highest selling American band of the 70s. Five #1 singles, six #1 albums, 6 Grammy Awards, 17 Top 40 singles, the highest selling album in U.S. history. They also have more longevity than Aerosmith, released their debut album in 1972 and are still going strong. They're more consistent than Aerosmith, no Eagles album has ever flopped while Aerosmith has released plenty of crap: Night In The Ruts, Rock In A Hard Place, Done With Mirrors, Nine Lives, and the atrocious Just Push Play. Not to mention Aerosmith sold out while the Eagles have stayed true to their roots even up to their most recent album in 2007 which went #1. Also Don Henley is by far a more intellectual and superior songwriter than Steven Tyler, who just writes about sex. Finally, you can't argue with the Eagles amazing body of work: Hotel California, Take It Easy, Desperado, Life In The Fast Lane, Tequila Sunrise, Lying Eyes, One Of These Nights, New Kid In Town, Heartache Tonight, Take It To The Limit, Peaceful Easy Feeling, Best Of My Love, The Long Run, Already Gone, I Can't Tell You Why, Witchy Woman etc. The Eagles are the Beatles of American rock while Aerosmith are the Stones.
  • JimmyColeman 2011/06/07 05:31:06
    The Eagles!
    JimmyColeman
    +1
    This question gave me a peaceful, easy feeling. That was so cheesy:(
  • Pinball Wizard 2011/05/11 09:00:51
    The Eagles!
    Pinball Wizard
    +1
    I have the Great Hits 1 & 2 CDs of The Eagles but, I do enjoys some Aerosmith's hits.
  • Rock4Life 2011/05/04 00:48:06
    Aerosmith!
    Rock4Life
    +1
    Sweet Emotion and..

    Are My favorite
  • Silent Bob 2011/04/17 18:33:34
  • Aerosmith!
    ♥EnjoyTheSilenceWhileItsThere♥
    +1
    OMG!!!!!!!!sweet emotion AHHHHHH!!!!!!!!!I LOVE THAT SONG!!!!!!!!!!!!
  • CiaoTopaz 2011/04/13 16:10:18 (edited)
    Aerosmith!
    CiaoTopaz
    +2
    I love ' em both ... But I Have to admit I love Aerosmith more!!! Lol
  • Vindessa 2011/04/12 17:43:16
    Aerosmith!
    Vindessa
    +3
    I love Steven Tyler
    love steven tyler Steven Tyler
  • Werkea 2011/04/11 20:10:32
    Undecided
    Werkea
    +2
    first TIME herd them
  • fullmoon 2011/04/11 19:38:48
    The Eagles!
    fullmoon
    +2
    i'll be living it up at the hotel california
  • Kyuketsuki 2011/04/11 17:36:05
    The Eagles!
    Kyuketsuki
    +2
    I like their sound better....
  • Stephen 2011/04/11 15:13:00
    Undecided
    Stephen
    +2
    I love them both for different reasons so I can't bring myself to choose one over the other.
  • Moonage 2011/04/11 13:53:36
    Aerosmith!
    Moonage
    +2
    The Eagles did it for a couple of albums. Aerosmith has done it for 40 years.
  • Moises ... Moonage 2011/06/29 09:06:36
    Moises Chavez
    +2
    Are you stupid? A couple of albums the Eagles were already an established band by the time Aerosmith finally found their break in 1975 with Toys In The Attic. The Eagles in the 70s dominated American music while Aerosmith found success with Toys In The Attic and Rocks before they began falling apart. Eagles released their self titled debut album in 72 followed by Desperado, On The Border, One Of These Nights, Hotel California, and The Long Run before breaking up in 80 as one of the greatest bands of all time. They eventually reunited in 94 and have been together and going strong ever since. They have released a more recent album than Aerosmith, Long Road Out Of Eden in 2007 which was a big success, and Aerosmith with Honkin On Bobo in 2004 which was an album full of blues covers. Eagles released their debut album in 72, Aerosmith in 73, so guess what, they've been around longer. Couple of albums my ass! They also happen to have the greatest selling album in U.S history and are the highest selling American band in US history, explain to me how they did that with a "couple of albums".
  • Moonage Moises ... 2011/06/29 14:51:33
    Moonage
    Aerosmith had more hits in the 90's than the Eagles ever did. They just so happened to have hits in the 80's while the Eagles were on hiatus. And, they had monster hits in the 70's. Now, according to wiki,

    the Eagles did the following studio albums:
    Eagles (1972)
    Desperado (1973)
    On the Border (1974)
    One of These Nights (1975)
    Hotel California (1976)
    The Long Run (1979)
    Long Road out of Eden (2007)

    Aerosmith did the following albums:
    January 13, 1973 Aerosmith
    March 1, 1974 Get Your Wings
    April 8, 1975 Toys in the Attic
    May 3, 1976 Rocks
    December 1, 1977 Draw the Line
    November 1, 1979 Night in the Ruts
    August 1, 1982 Rock in a Hard Place
    November 9, 1985 Done with Mirrors
    September 5, 1987 Permanent Vacation
    September 8, 1989 Pump
    April 20, 1993 Get a Grip
    March 18, 1997 Nine Lives
    March 6, 2001 Just Push Play
    March 30, 2004 Honkin' on Bobo

    January '73 vs 1972, not much of a difference there. 14 albums in four decades vs 7 albums in 2 decades ( the 70's and 00's, that's it ). Live albums I don't count because there's really no production value there. Singing songs you already know just doesn't take a whole lot of rehearsing.

    Aerosmith didn't have "break-up" years. They've been doing it for 30 years pretty much non-stop.

    Singles?

    Eagles Singles
    Top 10 10
    Total Weeks 282
    Total Songs 21
    First Year 1972
    ...



























    Aerosmith had more hits in the 90's than the Eagles ever did. They just so happened to have hits in the 80's while the Eagles were on hiatus. And, they had monster hits in the 70's. Now, according to wiki,

    the Eagles did the following studio albums:
    Eagles (1972)
    Desperado (1973)
    On the Border (1974)
    One of These Nights (1975)
    Hotel California (1976)
    The Long Run (1979)
    Long Road out of Eden (2007)

    Aerosmith did the following albums:
    January 13, 1973 Aerosmith
    March 1, 1974 Get Your Wings
    April 8, 1975 Toys in the Attic
    May 3, 1976 Rocks
    December 1, 1977 Draw the Line
    November 1, 1979 Night in the Ruts
    August 1, 1982 Rock in a Hard Place
    November 9, 1985 Done with Mirrors
    September 5, 1987 Permanent Vacation
    September 8, 1989 Pump
    April 20, 1993 Get a Grip
    March 18, 1997 Nine Lives
    March 6, 2001 Just Push Play
    March 30, 2004 Honkin' on Bobo

    January '73 vs 1972, not much of a difference there. 14 albums in four decades vs 7 albums in 2 decades ( the 70's and 00's, that's it ). Live albums I don't count because there's really no production value there. Singing songs you already know just doesn't take a whole lot of rehearsing.

    Aerosmith didn't have "break-up" years. They've been doing it for 30 years pretty much non-stop.

    Singles?

    Eagles Singles
    Top 10 10
    Total Weeks 282
    Total Songs 21
    First Year 1972
    Last Year 2003

    By decade
    1970's 17
    1980's 2
    1990's 1
    since 1

    Pretty much no production value at all after 1979. The two singles from the 80's were both in 1980.


    Aerosmith Singles
    Top 10 7
    Total Weeks 393
    Total Songs 27
    First Year 1973
    Last Year 2001

    By decade
    1970's 10
    1980's 5
    1990's 11
    since 1

    That train kept a'rollin right through the 90's.

    Although the Eagles have popped up lately, they took about 20 years off. During that entire time Aersomith kept on going. Some work better than other for sure, but that's not the question. Anyone can get lucky in music. Some do more than once. I don't deem one or two good albums as making a band great. Aersomith has been cranking it out pretty much non-stop for 30 years with pretty much the same line-up.

    I have no problems with my statement at all.
    (more)
  • Moises ... Moonage 2011/08/16 23:16:57
    Moises Chavez
    Aerosmith had 7 hits in the 90s.
    1-Living On The Edge
    2-Crying
    3-Crazy
    4-Amazing
    5-Falling In Love Is Hard On The Knees
    6-Pink
    7-I Don't Want To Miss A Thing
    Thats nowhere near your statement of them having more hits in the 90s then the Eagles ever did lmao. Aerosmith only had 6 Top 40 hits in the 70s, an era everyone likes to glorify them while the Eagles had 15! go figure. The Eagles broke up in 1980 and reunited in 1994. Though Aerosmith never officially broke up, they did take a few years off and band members left the group, Perry in 1979 and Kramer in 1981. Just because theyve released more albums than the Eagles doesnt make that a positive. Eagles have never released a bad album, while Aerosmith have released plenty of crap. Night In The Ruts, Rock In A Hard Place, Done With Mirrors, Nine Lives, and Just Push Play. For the record, the Eagles are the highest selling American band in U.S. history and the 3rd highest selling band of all time behind only Beatles and Led Zeppelin, both of which are British. You also cant deny the individual success that the members of the Eagles enjoyed outside the band, Don Henley, Glenn Frey, and Joe Walsh. In fact Don Henley as a solo artist had more Top 40 hits in the 80s then Aerosmith did. Don Henley had 9, and Aerosmith had 7. The Eagles didnt...
    Aerosmith had 7 hits in the 90s.
    1-Living On The Edge
    2-Crying
    3-Crazy
    4-Amazing
    5-Falling In Love Is Hard On The Knees
    6-Pink
    7-I Don't Want To Miss A Thing
    Thats nowhere near your statement of them having more hits in the 90s then the Eagles ever did lmao. Aerosmith only had 6 Top 40 hits in the 70s, an era everyone likes to glorify them while the Eagles had 15! go figure. The Eagles broke up in 1980 and reunited in 1994. Though Aerosmith never officially broke up, they did take a few years off and band members left the group, Perry in 1979 and Kramer in 1981. Just because theyve released more albums than the Eagles doesnt make that a positive. Eagles have never released a bad album, while Aerosmith have released plenty of crap. Night In The Ruts, Rock In A Hard Place, Done With Mirrors, Nine Lives, and Just Push Play. For the record, the Eagles are the highest selling American band in U.S. history and the 3rd highest selling band of all time behind only Beatles and Led Zeppelin, both of which are British. You also cant deny the individual success that the members of the Eagles enjoyed outside the band, Don Henley, Glenn Frey, and Joe Walsh. In fact Don Henley as a solo artist had more Top 40 hits in the 80s then Aerosmith did. Don Henley had 9, and Aerosmith had 7. The Eagles didnt have much hits in the 90s because they only released one live album in 1994 called Hell Freezes Over, which released two hits off of it, Love Will Keep Us Alive and Get Over It, both of which were bigger than any singles Aerosmith put out that year, which were Deuces Are Wild, Blind Man, and Walk On Water, none of which reached the Top 40. The Eagles also have had more hits in the 2000s than Aerosmith. Aero found one huge hit in 2001 with Jaded but ever since then have not found the same success. While Eagles found success with the single Hole In The World in 2003, and the two singles off their most recent album Long Road Out Of Eden in 2007, How Long and Busy Being Fabulous. Not to mention, the Eagles are still going strong touring and selling out shows while Aerosmith is trying to regroup after a tumultous two years dealing with Steven Tyler and his childish antics and group tensions.
    (more)
  • Kayla 2011/04/11 11:58:28
    Undecided
    Kayla
    +2
    Both so great!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
  • ...... 2011/04/11 11:46:33
    Aerosmith!
    ......
  • Iwan 2011/04/11 03:07:46
    Aerosmith!
    Iwan
    +2
    Almost a tie, but Aerosmith allows me to Dream On...
  • Firefly 2011/04/11 00:44:55
    Aerosmith!
    Firefly
    +2
    Seriously ??? omg ~ Aerosmith !!!

    I do LOVE the Eagles though ~ smiles, and jus'sayin' ~

    PEACE !!!
  • KK 2011/04/10 22:10:28
    Aerosmith!
    KK
    +2
    AEROSMITH dream on everybody!
    dont wanna miss a thing
  • DEUCE GIRL 2011/04/10 21:39:33
    Aerosmith!
    DEUCE GIRL
    +2
    i love them love aerosmith
  • Moises ... DEUCE GIRL 2011/06/29 09:08:40
    Moises Chavez
    +3
    Nine Lives was an awful album, one of the worst they have ever recorded.
  • DEUCE GIRL Moises ... 2011/07/01 14:38:53
    DEUCE GIRL
    +1
    who cares what ya say
  • Moises ... DEUCE GIRL 2011/08/16 23:21:33
    Moises Chavez
    dont get me wrong theyve recorded some great albums like Toys In The Attic, Rocks, and Pump but Nine Lives was not good at all.
  • DEUCE GIRL Moises ... 2011/08/17 18:05:23
  • mg's haven~POTL~PWCM~JLA 2011/04/10 20:52:04
    Undecided
    mg's haven~POTL~PWCM~JLA
    +2
    it would depend on what was going on around me
  • Germany~G.D.L.<3 2011/04/10 20:35:50
    Aerosmith!
    Germany~G.D.L.<3
    +2
    that's a tough question but I gotta go with Aerosmith
  • ghostrider 2011/04/10 20:32:09
    The Eagles!
    ghostrider
    +3
    For me, no one soars like The Eagles.
  • Lord of War 2011/04/10 19:49:37
    Undecided
    Lord of War
  • Selketskiss 2011/04/10 18:37:09
    The Eagles!
    Selketskiss
    +3
    That is a tough one but saw them in Tampa way back when and the were awesome plus I love "ALL" their songs like Those Shoes.
  • U-Dog 2011/04/10 16:41:51 (edited)
    The Eagles!
    U-Dog
    +3
    I like em both but IMO the Eagles have more depth and overall talent.

  • ruralntex 2011/04/10 16:33:23
    The Eagles!
    ruralntex
    +3
    Sorry Stephen Tyler, but the Eagles are the shyt!
  • Hey! I like your eyes<3 2011/04/10 16:20:37
    Aerosmith!
    Hey! I like your eyes<3
    +2
    I like the Eagles, but i love Aerosmith=)
  • Piwan 2011/04/10 16:18:40
    Aerosmith!
    Piwan
    +2
    VERY TOUGH ONE TO ANSWER!! BOTH are great, but I gotta tip my hat to Aerosmith. i saw them in 1994..I guess they are just more lively at concerts.
  • Moises ... Piwan 2011/06/29 09:10:14
    Moises Chavez
    +4
    I gotta agree with that, the Eagles are one of the better sounding bands live, but Steven Tyler does put on a great show, but then again so does KISS.......
  • SouthernB 2011/04/10 15:45:18
    The Eagles!
    SouthernB
    +3
    Both are really good groups, but taking all songs into consideration the Eagles have more, front end to back end, that I like.
  • Nika 2011/04/10 15:11:44
    Aerosmith!
    Nika
    +1
    They're both great but I listen to a hell of a lot more Aerosmith
  • kitty 2011/04/10 14:53:24
    Undecided
    kitty
    +1
    I couldn't decide. Love them both
  • Rainy 2011/04/10 14:13:34
    The Eagles!
    Rainy
    +3
    The Eagles were great. All you had to do is sit back, get comfortable, choose your drink and relax. They were the best music to listen to when you wanted to relax and take it easy.

See Votes by State

The map above displays the winning answer by region.

Entertainment

2013/06/19 12:55:15

Hot Questions on SodaHead
More Hot Questions

More Community More Originals