Submit News News
Ford, $1 Billion Profit, thanks Cash for Clunkers
- November 04, 2009 05:20:01
- Read all 17 comments
- +4 raves
- Results in North America were helped by much stronger sales than a year earlier, particularly in the United States, where the company was one of the prime beneficiaries of the Cash for Clunkers program that gave buyers up to $4,500 if they traded in a gas guzzler for a more fuel efficient vehicle.
"Suck it Obama haters." Said Mulally.... Read full article »
"Suck it Obama haters." Said Mulally.... Read full article »
Top Comment
-
now let the spinning begin.View thread
Also, is "Suck it Obama haters." an actual quote?
The question from the larger political perspective - was that an effective use of taxpayer money? Are we better off in the short run and will we be better off in the long run for having spent that money?
It's a pretty unfair comparison. The companies that took government assistance failed. They failed. We all know they failed. It's like comparing a Olympic winner to a guy that fell down and broke his legs.
The fact is that Fords success is proof that our government cherishes independent successful companies. The government did not force the car industry or take over the car industry, it offered assistance to the failed companies that needed it, to stop a massive economic downturn.
We hope that GM and Chrysler will come out independent and successful in the future, but without overdoing the assistance, we do not want to give an unfair advantage to these companies either.
Enlarge PhotoWhen Edmunds.com released its report on the Cash-for-Clunkers program on Wednesday, saying it cost $24,000 for each vehicle that wouldn't otherwise have been sold, it must have expected pushback.
It may not have anticipated, however, a sharp retort from the highest office in the land: the White House. But that's what it got yesterday, via a pithy entry on the White House blog calling the Edmunds analysis "implausible" and "faulty".
It not only refuted Edmunds' contentions by citing a report from the Council of Economic Advisors, but accused Edmunds of releasing sensational Clunkers analyses solely to draw media attention.
Is Edmunds right ?Cash for Clunkers banner with Mercury Sable, Albany, New York
Enlarge Photo
The original Edmunds.com analysis said about 125,000 of the 690,000 vehicles that replaced clunkers, or 18 percent, were truly incremental, i.e. they wouldn't have sold without incentives. Dividing the $3 billion program cost by that number gives an average cost of $24,000 per sale.
The Detroit News notes that Edmunds' percentage is far lower than estimates by the White House (64 to 81 percent), General Motors (72 percent), Moody's (60 percent), and Ford (20 to 30 percent).